Wednesday, 18 August 2010
Back in the UK
Thursday, 1 July 2010
Further musings...
Sunday, 27 June 2010
Port-au-Prince
On January 12 at about 4.50 in the afternoon “the” earthquake hit Port-au-Prince in the south of Haiti.
Officialdom records over 300,000 people having been killed, and the figure is more likely to be in the region of 500,000. The majority being buried in mass graves just outside the city. As in any disaster there are the, perhaps, expected stories of heroism and humanity, but also the rather shabbier accounts of self-interest and human exploitation.
Jean-Claude, Robyn and I flew to Port-au-Prince on a Saturday morning, as ostensibly this was the reason for our being in Haiti in the first place. The domestic and international terminal at Cap Haitien Airport is about 30 minutes from the centre of the city, and to get there involves negotiating the usual traffic obstacles – potholes, other drivers, pedestrians, lorries, tap-taps and a mass of motorcycles. We cross over the river, and the bridge is slowly returning to being a major trading area, as the memory of the earthquake slowly fades and with it the fear of a local recurrence.
At the airport our hand-luggage is x-rayed in common with anywhere else in the world, but the loud “beep” generated as we walked through the scanner seemed to generate scant interest.
Waiting in the “departure” area were several nuns – although Roman their precise orders were not obvious; an Episcopal Bishop and assorted other travellers. Flights were going to Port-au-Prince, The Turks and Caicos, and the Dominican Republic. Our plane could seat about 25, and was piloted by 2 pilots from the Dominican Republic. The flight took about 30 minutes, and we had clear views over the Haitian country, and it appears very green, and largely unpopulated.
Port-au-Prince from the air is at once much bigger than Cap Haitien, and it takes a while for the evidence of the earthquake to become apparent.
We are met by Spentz, who with his family have lived in Port for the last 8 years. He is a business man, and is clearly doing very well. He drove us around the city, and included areas of all degrees of prosperity, as nowhere was exempted from the damage. As he drove it was the almost casual comments that were the most disturbing:
“this was a school – 1300 children were killed here”
“just here a girl was saved after having her legs amputated, but the remaining 12 members of the family all died.”
“this was a bank – all the employees got out of the earthquake, but were killed by a gas explosion”
“on the day after the earthquake you couldn’t walk or drive down this street because of the masses of bodies lying on the road.”
All over the city there are piles and piles of rubble, a very little bit of salvage is being attempted – in the whole of the city we saw only one bull-dozer. There are a lot of tents, and rows and rows of “porta-loos” many of which are just outside the presidential palace. In the more prosperous areas there are more concerted attempts at salvage, but still people are living in tents in the garden.
Spentz was in his car when the earthquake struck – and tried to get out of it, but was not able. His children were at home with his sister, and all of them were unharmed. During the first night there were stories of extreme courage and acts of selflessness – whole communities working together to get people out, and when it was too dark and too late, there breaking out spontaneous services of prayer and hymn singing. But there are darker aspects too – the daughter of one of Robyn’s friends was trapped with a friend. The friend was freed, but because there wasn’t enough money to pay the extracting team her friend was left. Thousands of Haitian dollars exchanged hands in the immediate aftermath of the event.
Spentz was able to voice some of his concerns – and although he is a long way from being a politician it is people like him who are needed for the country – people who can stand back, and look away from self-interest, people who can recognise the faults and lessons to be learned from other countries, and who have a passion for the nation. Interestingly he is increasingly convinced for the need for very firm government – even the possibility of a dictatorship – to start the country back onto the long road of economic and social reform.
If we looked beyond the obvious signs of building destruction, it was very odd to see signs of “normal” life going on as before. On every street there were markets and stalls, as people try to eke out a living. Stalls as varied as sweets, second hand clothes, new suits, and car parts literally in front of piles of rubble the height of a single story building.
It became mind-numbing after a couple of hours, and the return flight became increasingly attractive. I think visiting the area was very important, if somewhat unpleasant, and even verging on the voyeuristic. But perhaps the most disturbing aspect of the visit was watching the reaction of Haitians back in Cap Haitien as they looked at the photographs we had taken: despite having lived with the reality of the events for the last 6 months, seeing them in silent tears was just too much.
Monday, 21 June 2010
From giving to receiving...
- I had been assiduous in taking anti-malarials, so if it was malaria the parasite might not have shown up;
- there is no specific test for Dengue fever (so I understand)
- and the samples were negative for Shigella, Amoeba, Giardia or Salmonella.
Friday, 18 June 2010
fevers...
Wednesday, 16 June 2010
A view from the roof top...
Tuesday, 15 June 2010
bits and pieces
A couple of photos to try and support my claim that I have been in theatre most days! And that the sun-tan has come from incidental exposure rather than anything planned. I am pictured with Drs Nadine Compet and Jo-Ann Jean-Louis. They are both residents - Nadine has 2 years experience and Jo-Ann 2 weeks! In the other picture is Dr Carmel Leconte - chief Anaesthetist, and only permanent member of the anaesthetic staff. She originally came from Port-au-Prince, but after her marriage she came to the north of the country. Her husband is the head of Obstetrics and Gynaecology at St Justinien.
Sunday, 13 June 2010
Sundays and other thoughts...
Saturday, 12 June 2010
Excursions to the country
grinding noises, and the car lost all power. So now we were stuck in the middle of some roadworks – with half the road only in use, cars coming towards us, and cars stuck behind us. We got out, and pushed the car forward for a few yards out of the immediate bottleneck and it quickly became apparent what was wrong – the drive shaft had disconnected at the universal joint. (I’m sure those mechanically minded will excuse me if I use the wrong term, and those not mechanically minded will recognise that the car would not go, and that something was hanging down from under it!)
I have been stranded in foreign countries before because of vehicles failing, and yet still I am not used to it. And being a natural pessimist wondered how we could deal with this problem. Did pray – but only half-heartedly – and at that point received a text from Lorraine hoping that I was enjoying my day off! It didn’t help matters to know that England were failing to beat the Americans at football at that very moment. But Robyn rang the owner of the car, who arranged to come out with some of his friends to fix it for us. A passing lorry driver had stopped and seen what was the matter, and could tell James exactly what he needed to fix the problem – I think it may have been little more than 4 nuts and bolts and some spanners, certainly no jack was involved.
So we had about an hour in the warmth – there was a breeze and so not too hot, watching and being watched by a selection of villagers, passers-by on foot, bike, motorcycle and Tap-tap, by
horses, mules, donkeys and chickens. There was even one enthusiastic jogger. Someone even volunteered the final result of the England match. We watched the road being graded and cleared and then sprayed with water to keep the dust down – very obligingly he turned off the hose as he past us, but it was fun to see the children running to keep up with the truck and its’ refreshing fountains.
And then Francois, Peter and James all arrived in an open top truck – along with the necessary equipment and an obligatory hammer. Their sentiments were “Your problem is our problem Miss Ro”. Francois and Peter got on with repairing the car, while James took us the remaining 15 minutes to complete our journey – this time on the back of a truck, dusty but fantastically refreshing.
Millot contains a hospital which has a better name than the one at St Justinien, and from all accounts is better equipped and set up to perform more complex surgery. It is a Roman Catholic hospital, and since the earthquake has been set up with a number of tents, or marquees, to act as wards and to provide accommodation for families. But we weren’t stopping there – our destination was Sans Souci - the palace (one of the 8 palaces) built by Henri-Christoph – the first “King” of independent Haiti. The Palace is next to a big domed church, and is near to a citadel – which was also built at the time in fear that the French would return to reclaim Haiti. More can be read about Henri-Christoph on Wikipedia, save to say he was born in Grenada, was a slave, and rose to serve in the French Army and proclaimed himself King. He tragically took his own life in 1820 at the age of 53 – fearing a coup. But the palace he built was at the time very spectacular – covered in mirrors and with a cannon at every window. The building was largely destroyed in the earthquake of 1843, but significant portions remain. Our guide was Charlo – and he spoke understandable, if quaint English: “this is the kitchen guard for if someone want to poison the feed”...
Our journey back was fantastic, as Kim and I opted for the open-top truck all the way home, which included the briefest wetting of sea-spray as we passed the coast – wind and waves stirring up the water. The journey finished with us teaching Peter to count in English – we had reached 35 when Enoch’s house was reached.
Bernadette had made some fantastic soup, and for the first time for a few day I was actually hungry. Church tomorrow – Enoch’s choir is leading some of the worship for one of the Harvest Festivals, and we have been warned that it will be very crowded... Pretty sure I will sleep tonight whatever the weather or power situation.
Churches...
Thursday, 10 June 2010
Torches and other things
This is going to sound like a piece of unmitigated advertising, but one of the best purchases I made for coming to Haiti was a Maglight pen torch!
We had been warned about the inevitability of power-cuts, but I wasn’t really sure what that would mean in practice. Robyn and some of the Haitians spoke darkly about periods of power-cuts lasting 4 weeks, but for my first 3 or 4 days there were none...
Then one morning I woke at 4.00am and realised that it was because of someone moving about outside and talking. And it took a moment to realise that I could hear them talking because the fan wasn’t working. The fan noise had become for me a bit like the background drone of a engine, or a “white-noise” masker that you can get to detract from the irritation of tinnitus. And so consequently I was spared from a lot of the normal noise that accompanies a house and street life. But with a power cut that distraction had gone, and I was aware of a lot more going on around me, and also a lot more aware of the heat! That time the power cut was for about an hour, and the relief was great when the motor re-started. But until the sun rises at about 5.05am – (yes, I have seen it rise) unless you are well aware of the surroundings a torch is a very handy device.
One evening I was using the torch to project patterns onto the wall – as the focus changes so do the patterns - and I was subjected to some good-natured teasing. I think the phrase “boys and their toys” was mentioned. The next day and the torch started to come into it’s own – in theatre one of the power-cuts happened while a patient in the lithotomy position, (the operation was for haemorrhoids) and the surgeon was literally working in the dark... Until that is the Maglight pen torch came into its own. (Not sure if it the sort of use likely to find its way into an advertising schedule) – but one added factor was that this patient was HIV positive, and it does not take much imagination to see how working in the dark with needles and scalpels puts the surgeon at significantly increased risk...
Also that night we were eating at a friend’s house – on the lower floor, and there was a power-cut – and the only torch was the same one (it had been at a long way away from the operation site) and verily it was a lamp unto our spoons, and a light upon our food....
And please try to remember the state of the streets, and the size of the manholes, and then you too can give thanks for a Maglight pen torch!
(The teasing about men and their toys was more than mitigated by the gift of some batteries for when the current ones expire.)
The Power cuts have got worse the longer we have been here: there seems to be a pattern developing: occasional loss during the day, but a fairly consistent stopping (all over Cap Haitien) at about 4.00am, for about 5 hours. This is the coolest part of the day, and so missing the fan is not such a problem. Many of the hotels – there are a few – have their own generators, and listening to them start up is sickening as we move as slowly and gently as we can to avoid over-heating.
The hospital clearly also has a generator – but it is not as reliable as it might be. Frequently during cases the lights are flickering on and off with the intensity of a fair-ground, and would be a risk factor for anyone with stroboscopic induced epilepsy. But it’s not only the lights: I am sure that the constant power surges are what damages the air-conditioning, and so after the first two or three cuts of the day the air-con functions only as a fan, circulating increasingly hot air. Ross was operating during one particularly florid bout of cuts and discovered that the diathermy machine had to be re-configured after every power drop – time consuming and irritating to say the least.
I am surprised how good-natured most people remain despite the conditions and equipment. There are very few raised voices in temper, and generally everything gets done.
As a post-script to previous postings: I was surprised to be told how few people drink the tap water when they have, and made a few more detailed enquiries, and in fact many Haitians do drink the tap water... Is there a surprise that during my first week here I was involved in the staged closure of an abdomen in a 10 year old boy: his original diagnosis was peritonitis secondary to typhoid causing a perforation of the large bowel?
Also on the Consent Form front: some patients, (so far only urology patients) do have a consent form in their notes, where the patient has consented to “Le procedure”....
Finally a couple of pictures to lighten the literary load: Ross involved in closing the originally typhoid-induced perforation (It was the first case of typhoid-induced perforation he had seen as well).
And the second – taken from a distance at the back of the surgical ward: a cleaner is filling her bucket from a well, and the container that she threw down into the well to collect the water is tied to pieces of suction tubing and IV giving sets!
PS As I am waiting for the pictures to upload the water in the tank has run out, and the electric pump has finally failed. It makes the Old Testament account of Abraham's servant being given water by Rebeccah (Genesis 24) and Moses giving water to Zipporah (Exodus 2) and Jesus by Jacob's Well (John 4) all the more credible...
Monday, 7 June 2010
More Hospital Musings
Being based in the Operating Theatres has meant I have less to do with the Hospital Wards than Dale or Ross. But having been to the surgical ward early in my time here it made a big impression on me. And obviously a deep one because Dale confided she was not looking forward to her first visit... Then having been on, she thought it was even worse than she had been expecting. But how much is bad – in any situation or circumstance? And how much is simply relatively bad? What is always unacceptable? And what is acceptable because of culture or condition?
Many, many of the Haitians are very moral, and hold high standards. For example at many of the churches it is not acceptable for women to wear short skirts or tight trousers, and Pastor Megy – from pulpit or more directly – has been known to ask people to sit “decently” to retain modesty. But in the theatre I was immediately struck by how patients arriving in theatre would often lie naked on the operating table, before anything was done to them, and on occasions for quite some time. But there was little sense of embarrassment or humiliation. And it is not limited to the theatre – I have heard about private out-patient clinics where patients are told to take off all their clothes and lie down until the doctor comes in – again with no sheet to cover them while waiting. But in theatre this is something I find uncomfortable – and whether interfering, or imposing my standards, I generally try to ensure patients are covered as much as possible...
The word that, for me, best describes the wards is “crowded”. Crowded with patients, beds, relatives and doctors. There are no screens, and on the surgical wards both men and women occupy adjacent beds. Relatives are essential because they provide the food, help with patient washing and dressing – both clothes and wounds, and in certain cases they buy the medicines.
They very often sleep under or beside the bed the patient occupies, but on the floor. The wards are roofed and walled with window spaces, but they have no glass – as it is not necessary because of the heat.
The surgical ward has a central courtyard which is used for treatment and washing – clothes and patients, and is usually buzzing with activity.
Patients are brought to theatre either by wheelchair or trolley – depending on the case, and the (by now expected) rules of driving apply with an interplay of artistry, ingenuity, goodwill and good luck ensuring not too many toes are run over or fractures bumped! Most patients arrive in theatre with an IV cannula in place, which is good as the heat is good at dehydrating. However consent forms are not used – just being on the trolley and in theatre is presumed as having given consent; and neither are any of the patients fixed with a name band, which is a big departure from the normal and expected practice in both the UK and New Zealand. (And for those who know what I mean – there is no pre-list “huddle”, and neither has the WHO check list made an appearance!)
On Sunday night (I was not involved in attack or treatment!) a local doctor was shot – either as part of an attempted kidnapping or as part of a robbery. He was in theatre for about three hours, and although he survived, he is currently paralysed from the waist down. He was going to be sent to the neighbouring Dominican Republic for further assessment and treatment. He still has the bullet in him. When I went to see him there were members of the UN sponsored Police Force – a Frenchman and an Egyptian, both in their local uniform, joining the general melee around his bed. They were wanting the bullet for forensic analysis, but realistically the assailants are unlikely to be found.
Dr Carmel Leconte had come in to anaesthetise the case, and was telling me today how she, who lives a few miles outside the city, feels unsafe if she is not home by 6.00pm, and when being driven to the hospital to attend to the case at 9.00pm and back at past midnight (by ambulance) she felt very nervous.
We were given strict instructions by Robyn not to venture out alone today– as she had to go to the Dominican Republic to collect the next member of the party – Kim (Physiotherapist) who is due in tomorrow.
On Mondays the theatre is given over to cleaning and emergencies only. While a minor emergency did materialise it was not possible to do anything because (again) the hospital had run out of oxygen. As it happened there was some teaching planned for the new interns and Anaesthetic nurses – and I joined in listening to a well prepared talk on Anaesthesia and Hypertension – delivered in French.
I quite enjoy regional anaesthetic techniques, and am waiting for the opportunity to teach interscalene nerve blocks, and if Dr Nadine is as competent and adept with them as she was with the epidural it will not be long before she is doing them unassisted. One big advantage with patients here is that generally they are not overweight – which makes every anaesthetic technique easier, and secondly (and to me I find this quite surprising) smoking is quite unusual.
Whereas tobacco use seems to be quite high in parts of Africa and Asia, it has a low prevalence here.
I am in two minds about photos to illustrate the wards: in general most Haitians love having their photo taken, but I wonder if it might be infringing privacy a bit too much to take some from the hospital wards. I will just try and add one from theatre – of Nadine after a successful epidural (taken with the patient’s consent!)